Solid not a solid?

Trying to get all solids in a nested family. (Family editor)
Some solids listing as surfaces. When is a solid not a solid?:thinking:

This part says it is a solid in the part family when I select the geometry.
In the Top-level famliy when i get it’s geomery in dynamo it shows as surfaces.

Imported geometry from SolidWorks using BIMDeX.


Is there a way to convert these to solids?

You could try the OOTB Solid.ByJoinedSurfaces node with your list of surfaces.

Hi Stephen
just try this out

filter the elements containing the surfaces use polysurface.byjoinedSurfaces node and make into a poly surface first and then use Polysurface.ExtractSolids node now you get a solid geometry then you can convert it into direct shape by using DirectShape.ByGeometry node

It looks to be a problem with Dynamo. The part in question is continuously coming up as a solid when queried in Revit. It only falls apart when being accessed in Dynamo. Any insight on this?
Attached the part file.Browning S T R1 T2 Bushing_2 9375.rfa (344 KB)

i have trouble similar with you, my result is line instead of surfaces. Have you ever got problems like this ?

This is a five year old topic (meaning whatever software in use at the time of the original posting isn’t supported anymore and is quite different as a result) and your data set and resutls differ from the original post.

Please start a new topic, including an RVT file containing nothing (new file, from template, none) other than one instance of the geometry that doesn’t convert.