Try using list levels, right now you’re choosing the 2nd list (which contain your five 1’s). If you use list levels you could get e.g. all values on the 2nd location in each list.
EDIT:
Firstly you should be careful both reading and writing to the same sheet of excel in the same graph… This can cause issues for large data-sets…
Also what changed from your previous post, where it didn’t assign the same values?