Element in Space not working for Ducts

Packages
, , , ,
1

does anyone know why the Archilab’s node “Element in Space” is not working with ducts anymore?

imagen
imagen1641×994 253 KB

I’ve been trying to figure why by looking at “Element.Location+” (Clockwork).

imagen
imagen1661×961 151 KB

Maybe some method changed because I found a node in Archilab specific for Ducts

imagen
imagen767×465 69.8 KB

And I also I found this post How to create a list that shows ducts contained within a space - #3 by Michal_Dengusiak
from 2016 In which, apparently, that node still worked for ducts.

Any guess? :slight_smile:

2

Hello…think ductlocation gives the location line and not the element…btw a duct can belong to many spaces

3

imagen
imagen1956×1106 250 KB

Yes, I know, but in “Element in Space”, from what I could understand the geometry the nodes gets the geometry from the element and then evaluate if the middle point of it is inside a given space. This is working fine for all of the other elements I have tested (Pipes, cable trays and so on) but it doesn’t for ducts